We store cookies on your device to make sure we give you the best experience on this website. I'm fine with this - Turn cookies off
Switch to an accessible version of this website which is easier to read. (requires cookies)

“Slow, inconsistent and negligent approach” to social care in pandemic. PAC report.

July 30, 2020 10:10 AM

"Slow, inconsistent and negligent approach" to social care in pandemic.

Not our words but those of one of the most senior House of Commons Committees, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC).


There have been some successes by the Government during the COVID-19 crisis, the Nightingale Hospitals a clear one, but a worryingly large number of failures. Especially when taken in the context of comparisons with similar developed countries. It's no great accolade when the only western country making the United Kingdom look good during this crisis is Trump's America.


But perhaps the greatest failure, and one we hope this Conservative Government will reflect upon, and apologise for, is the way Care Homes we're used as a 'dumping ground' to create capacity in the NHS.


This is the summary from the PAC report, it highlights some of the successes in tackling COVID-19, but also the abject failure by the Conservatives in the social care sector:

The Conservative failure during COVID-19.


The COVID-19 outbreak posed severe and immense challenges to health and social care services in England. After the first cases of COVID-19 in England were reported on 31 January 2020, the NHS and the adult social care sector had to act quickly to prepare for the impact of the pandemic within hospitals and care homes. By the end of April, the government had allocated an additional £6.6 billion to support the health and social care response, and £3.2 billion to local government to help with pressures on local services, including social care. On 15 May it announced a further £600m for infection control in care homes. We were told that in mid-March SAGE predicted that in the worst-case scenario more than 4% of the population might be hospitalised, and 30% of those would require critical care and that ICU capacity in London may well be breached by the end of the month, even if additional measures were in place.1

Thanks to the commitment of thousands of staff and volunteers and by postponing a large amount of planned work, the NHS was severely stretched but able to meet overall demand for COVID-19 treatment during the pandemic's April peak. From early March to mid-May, the NHS increased the quantity of available ventilators and other breathing support, which are essential for the care of many COVID-patients. The number of mechanical ventilators rose from 9,600 to 13,200. The number of beds available for COVID-patients also increased from 12,600 to 53,700 between mid-March and mid-April.

Unfortunately, it has been a very different story for adult social care, despite the hard work and commitment of its workforce. Years of inattention, funding cuts and delayed reforms have been compounded by the Government's slow, inconsistent and, at times, negligent approach to giving the sector the support it needed during the pandemic. This is illustrated by the decision to discharge 25,000 patients from hospitals into care homes without making sure all were first tested for COVID-19, a decision that remained in force even after it became clear people could transfer the virus without ever having symptoms.

Reflecting on the Government's response to the pandemic so far, we are also particularly concerned by its failure to provide adequate PPE for the social care sector and testing to the millions of staff and volunteers who risked their lives to help us through the first peak of the crisis. The Government needs to work urgently now to ensure that there is enough capacity-including both testing and PPE-and continued support for staff and volunteers so we are ready for future COVID peaks.

There are many lessons that the government must learn, not least giving adult social care equal support to the NHS and considering them as two parts of a single system, adequately funded and with clear accountability arrangements. No-one would expect government to get every decision right first-time round during such an emergency. Rather than seeking to give the impression that it has done so, the government urgently needs to reflect, acknowledge its mistakes, and learn from them as well as from what has worked.

This is our first examination of the health and social care response to COVID-19. The committee will be examining the ventilator challenge and the procurement of PPE in more detail in the autumn.


We would love to keep you updated. Please fill in your name below to be added to our mailing list.

  • If you submit this form, The Liberal Democrats will use your contact details to send you information on the topics you have requested. Any data we gather will be used in accordance with our privacy policy at centraldevon-libdems.org.uk/en/privacy. To exercise your legal data rights, email: data.protection@libdems.org.uk.